Thursday, October 19, 2006
I don't get it
It seems to me that there are two types of people in the world: those who love Hemingway, and those who hate him. Perhaps there's some connection between this division and the other major division I've observed: people who love cilantro, and people who hate cilantro. (Incidentally, although I am a cilantro-lover, I do NOT like cilantro with sand in it, which is apparently what I bought at the grocery store this week. Do you know how gross it is to eat pasta with sand in it? It's pretty gross--take my word for it, and don't try it at home.) Anyway, feelings about cilantro aside, the following query is addressed only to those love Hemingway:
Why?
During the course of the past few years, I've been trying to catch up on early 20th century American writers, as I somehow managed to miss most of them during my many years of schooling. And in the process, I've come across some pretty wonderful stuff. John Steinbeck? My new role model. Jack Kerouac? I may not always love everything he writes, but when he writes a good sentence...damn, it's a good sentence. And while I've never really understood all the hype around The Great Gatsby, even after multiple re-readings, I still have to admit that F. Scott Fitzgerald has a way of stringing words together that's nothing short of amazing.
But Hemingway? I don't get it. The guy just isn't a good writer. Granted, I'm only about halfway through The Sun Also Rises (chosen because I figured that at least it's about Paris and Spain, so how bad could it be?), but so far I've come across nothing to suggest that his works deserve the status they have attained. His sentence construction is simplistic at best, boring at worst, and the story so far seems to have no discernible plot. If he's a whiz at characterization, I can't tell, because I feel that I know preciously little about these characters so far. The blurb on the back of the book seems to suggest that it's a seminal work because it is symbolic of an entire generation, and the moral depravity and disillusionment within, but...uh, aren't most novels about the 1920s? (Maybe this is why I never liked The Great Gatsby. Yeah, people were wildly careless and morally bankrupt in the 1920s. We get it. Tell us something we don't know.)
So come on, Hemingway-lovers? What is it? Is it his whole cocky, swaggering, alcoholic expatriate aura? 'Cause I can see where that might be appealing to some people, but I like my writers to be able to put together sentences that demonstrate that they've at least advanced past seventh grade English.
Mark me down as a cilantro-loving Hemingway-hater.
It seems to me that there are two types of people in the world: those who love Hemingway, and those who hate him. Perhaps there's some connection between this division and the other major division I've observed: people who love cilantro, and people who hate cilantro. (Incidentally, although I am a cilantro-lover, I do NOT like cilantro with sand in it, which is apparently what I bought at the grocery store this week. Do you know how gross it is to eat pasta with sand in it? It's pretty gross--take my word for it, and don't try it at home.) Anyway, feelings about cilantro aside, the following query is addressed only to those love Hemingway:
Why?
During the course of the past few years, I've been trying to catch up on early 20th century American writers, as I somehow managed to miss most of them during my many years of schooling. And in the process, I've come across some pretty wonderful stuff. John Steinbeck? My new role model. Jack Kerouac? I may not always love everything he writes, but when he writes a good sentence...damn, it's a good sentence. And while I've never really understood all the hype around The Great Gatsby, even after multiple re-readings, I still have to admit that F. Scott Fitzgerald has a way of stringing words together that's nothing short of amazing.
But Hemingway? I don't get it. The guy just isn't a good writer. Granted, I'm only about halfway through The Sun Also Rises (chosen because I figured that at least it's about Paris and Spain, so how bad could it be?), but so far I've come across nothing to suggest that his works deserve the status they have attained. His sentence construction is simplistic at best, boring at worst, and the story so far seems to have no discernible plot. If he's a whiz at characterization, I can't tell, because I feel that I know preciously little about these characters so far. The blurb on the back of the book seems to suggest that it's a seminal work because it is symbolic of an entire generation, and the moral depravity and disillusionment within, but...uh, aren't most novels about the 1920s? (Maybe this is why I never liked The Great Gatsby. Yeah, people were wildly careless and morally bankrupt in the 1920s. We get it. Tell us something we don't know.)
So come on, Hemingway-lovers? What is it? Is it his whole cocky, swaggering, alcoholic expatriate aura? 'Cause I can see where that might be appealing to some people, but I like my writers to be able to put together sentences that demonstrate that they've at least advanced past seventh grade English.
Mark me down as a cilantro-loving Hemingway-hater.
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]