Wednesday, March 24, 2004

If I were an Idol...
Here's something I find puzzling about American Idol. Why is it that the contestants constantly talk back to the judges, yet kiss Ryan Seacrest's ass like there's no tomorrow? This makes no sense at all. The judges are essentially the ones in control of the contestants' fate, so shouldn't their asses be the ones getting kissed? Even at this stage of the competition, when the judges don't have a direct effect on who moves on from week to week, their opinions can still affect the voting habits of the American public. And at any rate, they're certainly more influential to the outcome of the show than Ryan Seacrest ever will be.

In fact, it seems to me that if one is trying to use Ryan Seacrest to garner votes, the best way to do this is by being rude to him. If his self-deprecating AT&T commercials are any indication, even he (or at least the marketing gurus at AT&T) realizes that by now, a large portion of the American public can't stand him. So why not try to appeal to this section of the voting community by turning the attitude on Seacrest for a change?

Let's take Fantasia Barrino, for example. Last night when Simon tried to give her what I believe was intended as a compliment (unless I'm totally out of it and calling someone young and fun and energetic is now an insult), Fantasia totally went off on him. Yet when she walked over to the stools and was subjected to yet another round of inane questions from Seacrest, she gave him the most pandering, mealy-mouthed answers possible. If it had been me, I would have done exactly the opposite. Here's how things would have gone had I been the contestant:

Simon: "The thing about you is that you're a very young, fun, energetic performer. But tonight you looked like an old lady. You look like your mother dressed you."

Me: [nod and smile] "OK."

Or, because I seem to remember Simon once saying that he thought Fantasia's exuberant performances were too over-the-top (or maybe that was just Chase), an alternate answer would have been:

Me: [in a respectful, non-mouthing-off manner]: "Well, I'm confused--before you said you wanted me to tone it down. Now I do, and you don't like it. What do you want me to do?"

Now we move on to Seacrest.

Seacrest: "We have to take a break now because I have to do my hair. My grass roots are showing, know what I mean?"

Me: "I don't know about grass roots, but I certainly see some black ones."

Or, as an alternate answer if we needed to stall for time:

Me: [blank stare] "No. That makes absolutely no sense. Who writes your lines, anyway? [peer at teleprompter] Oh my God, you're ad libbing this stuff? Seriously, was that the best you could come up with?"

Here's something else that puzzles me about American Idol: If Randy Jackson's entire repertoire consists of approximately four sentences, how the hell did he manage to write a book?

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Subscribe to Posts [Atom]